Nice article is in the making for a Dutch magazine, comparing the hottest hatches of the moment imho, the GT86 and M135i. Let me give you my verdict.
The GT86 is a sports car according to classic conceptions. Relatively light, naturally aspirated, requires revving and oversteer is easy to provoke. Perhaps it's best compared with BMW's E30. Easy performer even though it needs some experienced hands to go fast well, definitely not smooth, it's a car with character. A true modern day classic sports car.
The M135i is in a league of its own. The example on test, with X-Drive and the 8 speed auto box it is far from a raw sports car, virtually anyone can go fast in one of these. And if you go fast, you go real fast. Throttle response is amazing at any given speed or rev count, it just goes off and keeps on going off. With tons of grip and a PDK like gearbox you can hardly go wrong and then it's easy to give the GT86 a good beating.
But it is like comparing the E30 with the E36. Coming from an E30, things are just too easy in an E36, and too smooth. The E30 requires the driver to work, and then rewards the experienced driver with more driving fun and feedback than you'll get from the E36. The M135i is terribly fast, has a formidable exhaust note and it's a very well built car. A true BMW in many aspects.
But concluding like that would do the GT86 injustice. The BMW is a true BMW, but not a true sportscar in my opinion. The BMW may be faster, with a good driver the GT86 is definitely not slow or completely left behind, far from that. Considering its price tag (42K Euros vs 57K Euros in Holland), the GT86 is even more the thoroughbred sportscar than the M135i is. The 1M would be more in the GT86's class as for its approach to driving perhaps, but the 1M is more expensive big time. So overall, the GT86 would be my car. Let's hope that BMW's M2 concept (below, spy shots are also available on the web since a few days) will follow that good old tradition as well instead of becoming another luxurious FWD or 4WD heavyweight. There are already too many Audi's on this planet.
